Round Engagement Rings vs. Oval Engagement Rings - Read This Before You Buy

Engagement rings are more than just pieces of jewelry; they are symbols of love, commitment, and the promise of a shared future. Therefore, it's no surprise that much thought and consideration goes into picking the perfect ring. One of the most important choices you'll make in this process is selecting the shape of your center diamond.

Round cut diamond engagement rings have always been a very popular choice, but it's not to be overshadowed by the classic oval shape. In this article, we'll compare these two timeless options. Hopefully, by the end, you'll be equipped with the knowledge to make an informed choice, ensuring your perfect ring reflects your style and love story.

What to Consider When Choosing Your Diamond Shape

Appearance and Aesthetic

The visual difference between a round and oval cut diamond engagement ring is striking. With their symmetrical perfection, round rings offer a timeless and classic aesthetic. They gained popularity because they could maximize sparkle with their ideal symmetry. As such, brides seeking a brilliant, dazzling appearance often gravitate towards this shape.

On the other hand, oval engagement rings boast a unique and elongated shape that exudes elegance and sophistication. Ovals tend to create the illusion of longer, slender fingers, making them an excellent choice if you have smaller or shorter hands. The elongated shape of oval rings can also make your center stone appear larger than it actually is, adding glamour to almost any ring.

Trends and Popularity

We've already touched on the fact that round brilliant generally reigns supreme. Still, engagement ring trends ebb and flow with time, often influenced by fashion, celebrity choices, and evolving preferences. At various points in history, both round and oval engagement rings have enjoyed their moments in the spotlight.

Currently, round engagement rings are the number one choice, holding onto their enduring popularity. Oval engagement rings, on the other hand, have seen a resurgence in recent years thanks to their unique charm and versatility, making them a wonderful alternative choice. In the end, though, your ring should align with your personal style rather than trends.

Brilliance and Sparkle

One key factor that sets round and oval engagement rings apart is the stone's cut, which significantly affects brilliance. Round rings, with their symmetrical design and all-over faceting, maximize the play of light within the stone, resulting in superior sparkle and fire. Unsurprisingly, round-cut diamonds are often associated with classic glamour and luxury.

Oval rings offer a different type of sparkle. Their elongated shape creates a unique pattern of light reflection, characterized by flashes of brilliance that change with the viewing angle. Some individuals are drawn to this distinctive sparkle, finding it equally captivating.

Ring Settings

The setting choice is almost as important as the shape of your center stone. Additionally, both features interact with one another, meaning you can't consider the stone shape without considering it's setting. Round engagement rings are versatile and can be paired with various settings, from classic solitaires to elaborate halos, making them adaptable to different style preferences.

Oval engagement rings also offer some versatility in terms of settings. Still, they may not work as well with halos or three-stone designs. Nevertheless, their elongated shape allows for various creative designs, including vintage-inspired settings and modern, minimalist choices.

Stone Size and Carat Weight

The shape of the center stone can affect how big it looks. Round engagement rings often appear slightly smaller than oval rings of the same carat weight because of their shape. Round stones distribute their carat weight more evenly across their surface, while ovals concentrate it along their length. Even though an oval ring may weigh less, its larger surface area can make it appear bigger than a comparable round-shaped diamond.

If a larger-looking center stone is a priority for you, oval engagement rings are certainly the way to go. Generally, you can get a bigger-looking stone for less carat weight, which can also result in a lower price tag.

Cost

Cost is an important consideration for almost everyone when choosing an engagement ring, and we encourage you to consider your budget when shopping for either diamond shape. Round engagement rings tend to be more expensive per carat than oval rings. This price difference is primarily due to the higher demand for round-cut diamonds and the greater amount of rough diamond material lost during the cutting process to achieve that perfectly round shape.

Oval engagement rings, on the other hand, offer an opportunity to get more bang for your buck. Their elongated shape maximizes the appearance of size, making them an excellent choice for those seeking a larger-looking stone without breaking the bank. Plus, because they don't hold the number one spot in terms of popularity, they typically won't cost as much as their round counterparts.

Durability and Maintenance

Did you know that the shape of the ring can impact its durability and maintenance requirements? Thanks to their symmetrical design, round engagement rings tend to be more robust and less prone to chipping or damage. Their durability makes them a practical choice for individuals with active lifestyles or who want an heirloom piece to pass down through their families.

While still durable, oval engagement rings may have more vulnerable points at the tips of the stone due to their elongated shape. Fortunately, proper care, such as avoiding situations where the ring could be knocked against hard surfaces, can help maintain its longevity.

Personal Preferences

Ultimately, the choice between round and oval engagement rings is deeply personal. Your decision should reflect your unique style, preferences, and the symbolism you want your ring to convey. Don't focus solely on popularity, budget, or durability. Instead, consider what appeals to you aesthetically and emotionally, opting for the ring that best reflects your unique love story.

Round or Oval? There is No Wrong Answer

Before making a final decision, exploring both round and oval engagement rings in person or through an at-home try-on option is essential. See how different styles look and feel on your hand. Some jewelers may even be able to create digital representations of your dream ring, allowing you to virtually see how the shape works with your design, setting, and metal choice. Be sure to take your time to make a choice that resonates with you. And remember that beyond the aesthetics and trends, the most significant aspect of the engagement ring is the love it symbolizes and the journey it represents.