Reddit's Most Asked Questions About Diamond Engagement Rings—Answered!

If you've ever browsed Reddit for engagement ring advice, you know it's like stepping into a lively group chat with thousands of strangers. From proposal stories to passionate debates over natural vs. lab diamonds, the platform has become a go-to space for unfiltered insights on buying an engagement ring. Unlike friends or coworkers who might sugarcoat their opinions, the community keeps it real—and when you’re making such a big purchase, that kind of honesty is priceless.

So, we've gathered the most frequently asked questions from Reddit threads to help you navigate the exciting (and sometimes overwhelming) world of diamond engagement rings with confidence.

1. How much should you spend on a diamond engagement ring?

Aah! The most asked question, perhaps, both on and off Reddit!

The old “three months’ salary” rule once set the standard, but Reddit users largely agree it’s outdated. Instead, the community emphasizes spending what feels comfortable for your financial situation—especially when wedding costs and future goals are in the picture. The takeaway? Forget arbitrary formulas and plan your budget based on your reality.

Many also highlight the importance of factoring in lifestyle and personal preferences when choosing a ring.

Popular budget ranges discussed on Reddit typically land between $1,000–$5,000, though the “right” amount varies greatly by income, location, and values. Many couples share success stories of finding stunning rings within modest budgets by opting for lab-grown diamonds, which offer better value.

2. Is lab-grown really that different from natural diamonds?

This question usually sparks passionate discussions on Reddit!

Here’s the truth: The main differences lie in their origin, price, and personal values. Lab-grown diamonds are chemically, physically, and visually identical to natural diamonds. (People who’ve purchased a lab-grown diamond echo the same sentiment!) They also cost 30-50% less than their natural counterparts, which means you can get larger and often higher-quality stones without stretching your budget. Plus, you can upgrade other aspects of your ring, like adding pavé diamonds to the band or selecting a more intricate setting. Many couples also love their ethical and eco-friendly appeal.

So why do people still choose natural diamonds? For some, it’s the tradition, rarity, and long-term value that make them special—especially when thinking about heirlooms.

Still, most Reddit users lean toward lab-grown for the unbeatable value, often noting that it allowed them to get the exact stone they wanted without compromise.

3. What's more important—cut, clarity, color, or carat?

You're likely familiar with the 4 C's, but which of them is most important when shopping for a diamond or gemstone? The short answer: All of them are important!

But having said that, there’s a consensus among Reddit users, with most agreeing that cut is king.

TBH, we agree. A well-cut diamond will sparkle brilliantly even if other factors aren't perfect, while a poorly cut diamond looks dull regardless of its other qualities.

After the diamond cut, most buyers on Reddit suggest prioritizing color, clarity, and then carat.

If you’re on a budget, opt for diamonds with G-H color grade and VS1-VS2 clarity to get the best balance of beauty and budget. Also, choose diamonds with a carat weight slightly below the whole and half-carat marks. For example, a 0.90ct instead of a 1ct. They look nearly identical, but the price difference can be significant, and doing so can help you save a considerable amount of money.

4. Are round diamond engagement rings going out of "style"?

Not at all!

While 2025 has seen a surge in fancy shapes—ovals, marquise, pear, and cushion cuts gaining favor with brides seeking something distinctive—round brilliant diamonds still dominate the market.

Their unmatched sparkle, timeless elegance, and versatility make them the go-to choice, and their popularity ensures they’re widely available in various sizes, colors, and clarity grades. Trends may shift, but the round cut remains the enduring classic.

5. Is it weird to pick out the ring together?

Absolutely not!

In fact, Reddit discussions reveal it’s becoming more and more common. Shopping together ensures you’re both happy with such a significant purchase, and takes the guesswork out of sizing, style preferences, and budget goals. One user summed it up perfectly: “We designed ours together, and if I did it all over again, I’d still do it this way.”

That said, the surprise proposal isn’t going anywhere. Many couples strike a balance—discussing preferences ahead of time, browsing for inspiration together, then letting one partner make the final call. Some even propose with a placeholder ring before choosing the real one together afterward.

Across the board, Reddit users emphasize the importance of open communication. After all, an engagement ring is meant to be worn every day for a lifetime—so why wouldn’t you both have a say in making it perfect?

6. Do you think Engagement Rings need to have Diamonds?

No. The “right” stone is the one that feels meaningful to you as a couple because not all love stories look the same, and neither do engagement rings.

In fact, Reddit users are increasingly open to non-diamond engagement rings, with many proudly sharing their unique moissanite, sapphire, or emerald sparklers. Even lab diamonds are a popular choice for many. They come up frequently in threads as a smart alternative, offering the same sparkle and durability as natural diamonds with the added benefit of being more budget-friendly. Many couples share stories of choosing lab-grown and loving that they still get the brilliance and symbolism of a diamond without compromise.

7. What is the average carat size for an engagement ring?

On Reddit, most users report seeing engagement rings in the 1–2 carat range, though preferences vary widely by region and lifestyle. Still, the community emphasizes that sparkle matters more than size, and many even suggest going for a lab-grown diamond if you want to size up without sacrificing quality or budget.

And we agree! It’s a smart way to get the brilliance and presence of a larger diamond while still keeping quality, durability, and budget in balance. At the end of the day, the most impressive ring is the one that shines brightest to you—not the one with the biggest number on paper.

8. What is the difference between a wedding and an engagement ring?

This comes up on Reddit often, especially from first-time ring shoppers! The main difference lies in purpose and timing.

Engagement rings are traditionally given during a proposal as a symbol of the promise to marry. It usually features a center diamond or gemstone and is designed to be the standout piece in your wedding set.

Wedding rings (or wedding bands) are exchanged during the wedding ceremony. They’re usually simpler in design – think plain metal bands or ones accented with small diamonds – meant to be worn daily alongside the engagement ring.

That said, Reddit discussions highlight how modern couples are reinterpreting tradition: some skip the engagement ring, others stack multiple bands, and many design custom sets that merge the two.

9. My partner and I agreed on a cheap engagement ring. How do I get the most bang for my buck?

Reddit users are pros at stretching a budget, and budget-focused threads are full of creative hacks. Many share stories of finding stunning rings for just a few thousand dollars—or even less— by prioritizing smart choices over brand names or maximum carat weight.

Top Reddit strategies for budget shopping:

• Choose lab-grown diamonds for savings
• Focus on cut quality over size for maximum sparkle
• Consider slightly under milestone weights (0.9ct vs 1ct)
• Opt for G-H color grades instead of D-F
• Choose VS clarity over VVS for significant savings
• Shop online for better selection and pricing
• Classic solitaire settings cost less than elaborate designs
• White gold offers a platinum look at a lower cost

10. How to clean a diamond engagement ring at home?

This practical question generates consistent advice across Reddit threads, with users sharing tried-and-true methods for keeping rings sparkling.

We're happy that Reddit's favorite cleaning method is a safe one. Here's how:

1. 1. Soak in warm water with gentle dish soap for 20-30 minutes
2. 2. Gently scrub with a soft toothbrush, focusing on the back of the diamond
3. 3. Rinse thoroughly with warm water
4. 4. Dry with a lint-free cloth

Here are a few things to avoid:

• Harsh chemicals like bleach or chlorine
• Ultrasonic cleaners at home
• Abrasive materials that could scratch the metal
• Cleaning over an open drain

Additionally, we recommend professional cleaning every 6 months and having your jewels inspected for loose stones every few months.

Wrapping Things Up

Navigating the world of diamond engagement rings can be daunting, but with the right information, it becomes an exciting journey. We hope this deep dive into Reddit's most-asked questions has cleared up some of the confusion and empowered you to make a confident decision. Remember, the perfect ring reflects your unique love story, fits your budget, and brings a smile to your face. By focusing on the fundamentals—the 4Cs, lab-grown vs. natural diamonds, and finding a trustworthy jeweler—you're well on your way to selecting a ring that will be cherished for a lifetime. Happy ring hunting.