Diamond Studs vs. Gemstone Studs: Which Sparkles Brighter?

Diamond Studs vs. Gemstone Studs

Diamond and gemstone studs are must-have pieces for your jewelry collection. They both look fantastic and are timeless earrings that will always be in style. If you could only choose one style of studs, which would you choose – diamond or gemstones? We'll help you decide to see what's best for you.

Introduction to Diamond Studs and Gemstone Studs

Stud earrings are more subtle and minimalistic looking. They're typically one stone or a small cluster of stones that sit close to the earlobe. Both diamond and gemstone studs are popular choices and are timeless designs that you'll wear for years.

Composition and Characteristics

Both gemstone and diamond studs provide a classic design with timeless stones. Diamond studs are made with incredibly durable stones. They're a 10/10 on the Mohs hardness scale, so they're a strong stone built to last. Diamonds come in different types of quality that are graded in the 4Cs – color, clarity, carat weight, and cut. Color is the stone's hue, while clarity refers to the inclusions within the stones. Carat weight is the total weight of the diamond and how big it is. Cut means how well the diamond is cut for maximum brilliance, sparkle, and shape.

If you're thinking about gemstone studs, you'll want to select a quality stone that will be durable for earrings. Rubies, emeralds, sapphires, amethyst, and topaz all make great choices for stud earrings. For example, rubies are a 9 on the Mohs hardness scale, and topaz is an 8. Color is important for colored gemstones – you'll want to choose a stone with the level of saturation and vibrancy that you like.

Value and Rarity

Diamonds are extremely rare, so they're more valuable and will cost more. Colored diamonds are even rarer. Gemstones like Tanzanite are rare colored gemstones, but red is the rarest color of gemstones. The rarity of stones impacts the price, as does the quality. Higher-quality diamonds and gemstones will cost more because they're harder to find. You will need to balance the quality grades with your budget to see what works best for you.

Brilliance and Sparkle

Sparkle and brilliance depend on different factors. For example, diamonds let light into the stone and then reflect and refract it. Diamonds have 58 facets that help make the most of the light that enters and exits the stone. Other gemstones, such as rubies, have different optical properties and won't sparkle in the same way as diamonds. Gemstones and diamonds both have sparkle, but they look different.

Variety and Color

Each colored gemstone will vary in color as well. You'll see gemstones that are more saturated while others look paler. Color is an essential factor for gemstones because you want a vivid color. Higher-quality colored gemstones will have fewer inclusions and pure color and be cut so that the facets are symmetrical and proportionate. For earrings, you want each earring to match so they look like they belong together.

For diamonds, the colorless versions are higher quality than diamonds with a tint of color. The color of the diamond depends on your preferences and budget. Some like a warmer diamond with a lower color grade, while others prefer a colorless, icy diamond with a higher quality grade. Try to select diamonds that are comparable so the earrings look like a set.

Symbolism and Personalization

Each month has an associated birthstone. For example, April is a diamond, and July is a ruby. You could select birthstones or a favorite color for gemstone studs. If you're celebrating a milestone, perhaps pick the birthstone for that particular month as a sentimental and personal gesture. The possibilities are endless, and you can easily make a pair of earrings.

Fashion and Trends

You'll see studs in a variety of styles beyond solitaire studs. Halo studs, climber earrings, and toi et moi are styles that have become more popular in recent years. You might be surprised to know that you can even get colored diamond stud earrings! Browse different styles to see if you're leaning toward a classic look or one of the more trendy designs. No matter what, you'll find plenty of stud options.

Ethical and Environmental Considerations

Lab grown diamonds and gemstones have become more popular as more men and women have learned about the gemstone and diamond industry. Lab created stones typically cost less, is ethically sourced, and is more environmentally friendly than mined stones. They're a good alternative for those concerned about the diamond and gemstone industries.

Budget Considerations

It's helpful to consider your budget before browsing for gemstones or diamond studs. This can help you narrow your options and streamline your shopping. The price of your studs will depend on the quality of the stones and the type of stone. If you're concerned about your budget, consider lab grown diamonds. Consider smaller studs if you're trying to cut costs because bigger stones will likely cost more.


Diamond and gemstone studs both look stunning on – they're versatile pieces of jewelry that will always be in style. Diamonds offer elegance in a classic style. Gemstone studs provide a pop of color, whether it's a birthstone, their favorite color, or simply the gemstone they adore the most. Consider your style, budget, and preferences as you choose between diamond and stud earrings. Both options are excellent, and you'll be happy with your choice!

4.8 Google review stars

Read our reviews