With Clarity

38 West 48th Street, New York

4.8

Rhett Diaz

1 review

Jon Harty

1 review

With Clarity in conjunction with Rare Carat helped me out of a bind after a fiasco with another diamond business. They were very accommodating and their prices are just as stunning as the diamonds. After purchasing the diamond they provided us with swift service and had the diamond within no time. I cannot thank you guys enough for saving my engagement.

Rami Saidi

1 review

I had to place my ring order before traveling overseas in 9 days. I called them and they made special arrangements to send it by 9th day ( usually its 10 working days) they even managed to get it engraved! I am pleased with thier service.

Jake Aspenleiter

1 review

Couldn't be any happier! Bought my fiancée an engagement ring and band from Four Mine, which is now With Clarity, and she is over the moon. The number of compliments she get's on the ring tenfold of what I would've expected. Very competitively priced, would highly recommend!

Sinthu Kanga

1 review

These guys are amazing! Claudia and Sade really helped me out with every step of the process. I had a tight deadline as I was flying out to propose abroad and the With Clarity team assured me they would be able to deliver on time which they did. I was hesitant about ordering an engagement ring online at first and how my custom ring would turn out, but when I finally got the ring it was perfect and exactly what I'd wanted. The pricing for the custom work was also unbeatable, well done!

Josh Mulrooney

1 review

First, I just wanted to say I have not been compensated for this review, nor do I have any affiliation with With Clarity. Some reviews I read and think they have to be getting compensated for writing such a lengthy detailed review. That is not the case here, I just feel the value that With Clarity has presented me deserves a detailed review. I was looking for a good promise ring for my girlfriend for our one year, she is very picky about what she likes when it comes to rings (thin pave rose gold band with a single center stone.) I looked online many places like Zales and Kay and others and none of them had what I was looking for. I looked in stores at jewelers and rings similar to the ones she liked were all thousands of dollars. That’s when found sites where you could chose a band and a loose GIA certified diamond like Blue Nile and Adiamor (I strongly recommend you stay away from Adiamor, their customer service is very rude and unable to answer your questions) but their rings were all close to $2,000 for what I was looking for. I even was debating on buying an uncertified ring from Etsy because those were as close to what she wanted as I could find for under $1,000.. That’s when I stumbled upon With Clarity. I searched their site for a Petite French Set Diamond ring a few settings popped up and I found a beautiful rose gold pave setting for $980 and a .50ct E clarity VS1 diamond for $780 I thought that sounded like a way better deal than other rings I’ve seen with H/I clarity and SI diamonds that were still more than this one. Plus it shows you a 40x magnified view of every angle of the diamond in 360 degrees so you know exactly what you’re getting. It was a little more than I was planning on spending though, so I kept looking along their site and found an 18ct rose gold petit French set ring for $120. The stock image was animated so I asked if it was real rose gold and diamonds and they verified that it was genuine 18ct rose gold (75% gold 15% copper and 10% silver) and informed me that it takes 12 business days to craft their rings and ship them out. I was skeptical about the setting, but the diamond was such a good deal (the Washington diamond value estimator said this diamond was valued at $1460) i had to order the ring. With a 30 day return policy I thought I’d just return it if it wasn’t what I expected. But i still a .50ct certified diamond set in a 18ct petite rose gold pave diamond ring exactly how she likes for $900 shipped.. I thought it was too good to be true. I ordered my ring June 5th and it arrived today, Thursday June 20th and it is beyond perfect, its exactly what I hoped it was going to look like. I think With Clarity should do 360 degree views of actual pictures of the settings instead of animated ones because the animated photos don’t do the ring justice. For being a custom ring I think two weeks is a very reasonable time to wait. Once you factor in how much cheaper it is to buy a loose diamond and setting from With Clarity, their free ring resizing, 30 day return policy, and phenomenal customer service, you’d be crazy not to buy from them. I planned on spending under $500 on a dainty promise ring for my girlfriend for our one year, but when I saw this ring, the exact style she likes I had to take a chance and order from With Clarity and I am so glad I did. The value here is unbelievable. I can’t wait to give the ring to my girlfriend tonight! Thank you so much to Sade, Claudia, and Alex for answering all my questions and getting my ring shipped out quickly! Update to the already lengthy review: The ring was a bit too big (She said she was a 7.5 but she was a 7) so I emailed With Clarity and they responded so quickly and got me a shipping label that same day I emailed them about the free resizing! I also had the ring engraved when it went in for the resizing and it was done in under a week! It came back as beautiful as ever with no traces of being resized, this is truly a great company, I’m not sure why you would use any other online jeweler! Thanks With Clarity!!

Dimitrios Chlorokostas

1 review

Best value for money online diamond shop after long research. And I liked the add-on features with free resizing and 30-day money back guarantee they offer.

Doug Wells

1 review

George Guerrero

1 review

Joe Shelby

1 review

We looked all around Atlanta for the perfect engagement ring and could not find it. Then we did some research on the internet and came across Four Mines. My future bride saw the ring on line. I was able to go through all the stones until we found the perfect one. We used their 3D visual simulator to look at it. It was exactly what she was looking for. I placed the order online and was given a shipping date. I was notified when the ring was sent by FedEx. It arrived in a nice black block along with all the paperwork about the diamond. She was thrilled when I asked her to marry me and placed it on her finger. From start to finish it was simple. At any point I could have just called them for help. I highly recommend Four Mines.

Timothy Henderson

1 review

Selection was great - diamond videos was super helpful and much better than seeing diamond in a store because they all look the same under those lights! Shipping was fast and delivered within the timeframe promised. They helped me choose between my final two options - the gemologist was very knowledgeable with specific technical reasons for why I should choose one or the other. Most other “gemologists” would just say generic things to try and sell. Overall very happy with my order. Would recommend to others

Sally Pulaski

1 review

I purchased a 2ct diamond ring at With Clarity. The ring is gorgeous! I did months of research before making my decision and I have no regrets. We will be back for wedding bands also. They also easily have the best service - kudos to the team.

Cristian Perez

1 review

Jacob Farran

1 review

I purchased a $1600 men’s diamond wedding band and Four Mine/With Clarity can not resize the ring unless I pay another $1600 for them to re-craft the ring due to the milgrained design. The design is called channel set and milgrained diamond wedding band. Since I waited more than 30 days to get it resized, I had to pay $70 to ship it to Four Mine/With Clarity to resized which is reasonable but for this price they will only add beads to the inside of the ring which look tacky and are uncomfortable. My only other option is to take the ring to my local jeweler who also said they would have difficulty resizing the ring due to the design. Overall Four Mine/With Clarity has demonstrated terrible customer service and they were not straightforward with the product they were selling me. Now I’m stuck with a $1600 ring that is nearly impossible to resize. Utterly ridiculous and a ripoff. I would recommend avoiding FourMine/With Clarity at all costs!!

Gladys Dominguez

1 review

I LOVE MY RING! We had purchased one with James Allen but didn’t like it when it came. So we returned it and tried Four Mine. We were both stunned by the ring when we received it! It was reasonably priced compared to the other sites and it was such a great steal! The box it came in was black and presentable; came with the diamond info. I at no point have had second thoughts about this ring. It’s the one! I was able to ask tons of questions and they responded within hours. I don’t mind paying for the shipping so that they can clean it. It’s still cheaper than my local jewelry store. One thing that was a little confusing was the FedEx shipping. This was not at all due to Four Mine. This was a FedEx problem. They stated they would come at the end of the day but ended up coming around noon. I would encourage everyone to pick it up at their local FedEx location if possible so that you don’t miss them. I rerouted mine to the local FedEx and picked it up the following day.

oogle Reviews

4.8